Yes he is, and I think this would be a good idea... Too bad it is a long and time consuming task, and it can be inaccurate... Say I had my network on there, and my ISP decides to be crappy the day that they check. Mine would be marked as dead, when in reality, it would be quite lively.
This also requires a ton of maintenence. It isn't something that needs to be done just once, but constantly (weekly/monthy). I think I would prefer the coders doing something more development-oriented (like coding)
Yes, I was talking about unrealircd.com. Sorry I forgot to mention it.
It doesn't have to be real time, The list is not too huge so ONCE a month would do. Someone could take 5 minutes of his time and just check the sites and see if they work or not.